From Evangelical Pastor to Orthodoxy: Lessons in Humility

Reflections on my journey from Protestant pastor to the Orthodox Church, the mistakes I made along the way, and the costly lessons I learned from misplaced zeal.

I am an ex-Evangelical pastor who converted to Orthodoxy. Below, I have put together my story, taking time to reflect on some mistakes made along the way, in the hope that it may be helpful to other converts.

Restless conscience

I began following Jesus around the age of 19. By age 24, right as we married, my wife, Bekah, and I became Reformed Baptists and joined a non-denominational church. We spent almost 10 years there—sharing weekly meals, hosting people in our home, raising children together, serving on ministry teams, and for around 2 years I served as a deacon; all the while, the lead pastor mentored me for ministry.

Toward the end of our time there, two issues began eating at me. First, while discussing Calvinistic election, sovereignty, and double predestination with a dear friend, I backed myself into a corner and caught myself admitting that I essentially believed God was the author of evil. My stomach turned as I kind of just intuitively understood how wrong that was.

Second, studying the scriptures convinced me that following Jesus required more than ‘faith alone,’ and I was becoming unsettled by how naturally my religion up to that point was forming me into a spectator, when instead, Jesus was asking me to be a follower.

Share

Read also