JD Vance: Criticizing Israel Is Not Antisemitism
Vice President JD Vance said opposing Israeli policies is not the same as antisemitism, sparking debate over where criticism of Israel ends and hatred of Jews begins.
WASHINGTON, D.C. — Vice President JD Vance said this week that criticism of the state of Israel should not automatically be labeled antisemitism, drawing a clear distinction between opposing Israeli policies and hatred toward Jewish people.
Vance made the remarks while responding to an Atlantic article suggesting younger generations are more antisemitic than older ones. He argued the issue is less about age and more about immigration and assimilation, contending that reducing immigration from countries hostile to Jews would do more to combat antisemitism than generational analysis.
Addressing online commentary, Vance emphasized that “not liking Israel” or disagreeing with its policies is fundamentally different from antisemitism. His comments sparked debate, with some commentators arguing that anti-Zionism often fuels hostility toward Jews, while others, including non-Zionist Jewish groups, welcomed his distinction.
Vance’s position contrasts with that of several Republican leaders who have equated criticism of Israel, particularly over Gaza, with antisemitism.
Previously in the UOJ, Fr. Zechariah Lynch delineated Christians' relationship with Israel.
